The Chemistry World website tweeted yesterday a report of malpractice
at a forensics laboratory in Oregon. Nika Larsen, a forensic scientist at the
Bend Crime Laboratory, allegedly would take drugs and other items from samples
she was testing and replaced them with OTC drugs. The District Attorney of the Deschutes County
said they will have to review 1500 criminal cases in which Larsen analyzed
evidence.
Another forensic scientist in Oregon, Jeff Dovci, who retired from the
Central Point Lab in 2013, has come under scrutiny because of his testimony in
a 2005 trial. Although the convictions
in that case were overturned in 2012 for reasons unrelated to Dovci’s
testimony, an examination of his court records has cast doubt on his testimony.
Back in 2013, Annie Dookham, A Massachusetts forensic scientist, was
sentenced to 3 to 5 years in prison for falsifying thousands of drug tests,
which could affect the convictions of over 1100 defendants. In their October 2012 report of the Dookham
case, Chemistry World included a quote from Josh Lee, a criminal defense
attorney in Chicago, who teaches forensic chromatography.
“Forensic science is very much a ‘wild, wild west’ where everyone does
what they want.” There is no true
oversight such as the pharmaceutical industry or the Environmental Protection
Agency’s labs.
Seriously? Why not?
Shouldn’t we be as concerned with the forensic laboratories and the
manner it collects, analyzes and stores samples? How many innocent people were convicted based
on testimonies from Larsen and Dookham?
How many were guilty and got away?
How much money is it going to cost tax payers to review all the cases to
determine if a re-trial is warranted?
These are just two examples.
There have been cases of forensic scientist fraud in Pensacola, Florida
and Walker County, Texas.
Making processes such as training and maintaining documentation
mandatory will not solve the problem, since there will always be unscrupulous
laboratory workers, but it would add more layers of supervision. And tougher penalties. Labs won’t be able to operate with a ‘wild,
wild west’ attitude. The EPA has had to
send out the SWAT team but these incidents have been much fewer.
Environmental chemists are working their butts off to maintain their certifications. Make the forensic chemists do the same.
http://www.rsc.org/chemistryworld/2015/09/forensic-drug-crime-lab-malpractice-oregon