Showing posts with label Honolulu mysteries. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Honolulu mysteries. Show all posts

Tuesday, October 9, 2018

Book review - "Murder Casts a Shadow" by Victoria Nalani Kneubuhl


I picked up this book when we were in Hawai’i two years ago, looking for inspiration for my own Hawai’ian mystery.  Kneubuhl is a Honolulu playwright and writer for a television series “Biography Hawai’i”.   It is the first book in a series of mysteries set in 1930s Hawai’i.


Set in 1935 Honolulu, the story opens as the new year starts when a museum curator is found murdered.  A priceless painting is stolen from the museum at the same time.  (I felt a Daniel Silva-esque novel coming on but was quickly appeased.)  Kneubuhl’s sleuths are a British-speaking Samoan-born Ned Manusia and Mina Beckwith, a Honolulu socialite and newspaper reporter of Polynesian descent.  Despite the fact, Mina’s twin sister Nyla is married to a local police detective Todd Forrest, Ned and Mina take on the mystery themselves, since Ned brought paintings from England for display.

It isn’t long before the painting is recovered.  With art theft removed as a motive for the murder, Ned and Mina have to determine what is.  By now, more people are killed and they stumble upon a possible cover-up of the U.S. government having a hand in Hawai’i’s last king’s death, over forty years before.  King Kalekaua died in San Francisco in 1891.  The official cause of death is listed as Bright’s disease, an inflammation of the kidneys, but Kneubuhl’s story entertains the idea that he was poisoned to pave the way for the U.S. government to end the monarch and annex the islands.

Not really a stretch of the imagination.

Kneubuhl infuses a lot of history, imagery and the environment of mid-1930s Hawai’i but they come across as data dumps and tend to take the reader out of the story.  Also, she describes Mina’s and Nyla’s clothes in every scene but unnecessarily.

Oh, well.  It’s still a good read.

3 🌈🌈🌈 out of 5

Saturday, September 17, 2016

Book review - McDougal's Honolulu Mysteries


I was a bit confused reading McDougal's Honolulu Mysteries, an anthology, edited by Glen Grant.  According to the notes, the stories are oral histories from Arthur McDougal, a detective in 1920's-1930's Honolulu.  Hawai'i is U.S. territory, not a state.  People still remember, and are bitter about the end of, the monarchy.  The book is more detective noir fiction, rather than a whodunit.  More answers by fist, instead of the little, gray cells.

At the end of each story, Grant inserts a note discussing the validity of the events in McDougal's adventures, which in very few of them, can he.  Therefore, my question is: Was McDougal a real person?  I can't tell and I can't find out, either.  It took away from the enjoyment of the book (a little) because it read as McDougal is a fictional character.

Still, the book was a fun read.  I most enjoyed the first and last stories, which had elements of the paranormal.  And some were true whodunits.

The glimpse into Honolulu's past was one of the pluses of the book.  The stories, not in chronological order, occur from just after WWI to 1934.  Places, events, and events of the era give the stories an authentic feel.

McDougal's Honolulu Mysteries: Case Studies from the Life of a Honolulu Detective is a good read. It's more along the lines of Raymond Chandler and Dashiell Hammet than Agatha Christie.